Voodoo5 Vs. Geforce2 Ultra

I'm going to be getting a job soon, and i plan on trying to turn my computer into a massive gaming computer, but i'm stuck on what video card i should get, i've had experience with voodoo cards and there preformance has been quite pleasing, so i've been heading towards Voodoo5 AGP, but i've also head from friends t ...

Windows Hardware 9627 This topic was started by ,


data/avatar/default/avatar08.webp

4 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-10-06
I'm going to be getting a job soon, and i plan on trying to turn my computer into a massive gaming computer, but i'm stuck on what video card i should get, i've had experience with voodoo cards and there preformance has been quite pleasing, so i've been heading towards Voodoo5 AGP, but i've also head from friends that the Geforce2 Ultra outpreforms the Voodoo5 in a wide range of fields, your guy's advice would be appreciated

Participate on our website and join the conversation

You have already an account on our website? Use the link below to login.
Login
Create a new user account. Registration is free and takes only a few seconds.
Register
This topic is archived. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast.

Responses to this topic


data/avatar/default/avatar28.webp

70 Posts
Location -
Joined 1999-12-29
just up the res and so FSAA doesn't matter. i think not, even if you put the to 1600X1200 1024X768@4xFSAA, looks a hell of alot better, think i would even prefer 1024x768@2xFSAA. do be honest i play most games in 2xFSAA and not 4xFSAA, although 4x would make the image loads nicer, because it does it 4x and also because it does it using a different method at 4x i believe, but the fps impact in alot of games is just abit to much. i mean, in win2k 1024x768@2xFSAA with 16bit colour, 32bit texture quality, everything else on full. 52fps on demo1 is very playable and looks very very nice. not the fastest in the world but looks a hell of alot better than any other card. Also 1024x768@4xFSAA in motorcross madness2, oooooh thats just so sweet. i can push it up to 1280x1024 but thats down to about 20fps, although i wouldn't know if i didn't have the indicator on becuase it runs smooth as a babies bottom.
(sorry for going on abit)

data/avatar/default/avatar12.webp

1915 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-03-30
I'll put my two cents into this one.
 
No contest Geforce 1 or 2 ,Ultra or non kicks anything 3fdx has put out ...right in the ass. If you wanna play your Direct 3D games in 640 x 480 with 4X FSAA then buy a 3dfx product. You wanna jack up all the settings at any res and still be smooth..buy an Nvidia product..
 
Last good card 3dfx made was a Voodoo2
 
I have 3 machines ...needless to say my third has a voodoo in it. the one i least use
 
[This message has been edited by sapiens26 (edited 12 November 2000).]
 
[This message has been edited by sapiens26 (edited 12 November 2000).]

data/avatar/default/avatar06.webp

144 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-07-14
Dude don't listen to anyone here.
 
Go for the ****ing geforce 2 GTs..
 
hands down
 
The Leadtek Winfast Geforce 2 GTS is the best for the price, but there are 64mb DDR ram versions out (AWESOME!)

data/avatar/default/avatar32.webp

671 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-05-04
I recently turned on FSAA on my GF2 Ultra whilst playing HalfLife in OpenGL. At the max res (1152 x ? IIRC) there were quite a few jaggies along the tops of walls.
 
I turned on max FSAA, the jaggies vanished, and there is no visible hit in performance.
 
------------------
PIII 800EB FC-PGA
Intel D815EEA Motherboard
Intel:registered: PRO/100 Integrated NIC
2x256MB PC 100 RAM
Maxtor 92049U6 20.4GB 7200RPM UDMA66
Maxtor 52049U4 20.4GB 7200RPM UDMA66
Hercules 3D Prophet II Ultra 64MB
AOpen 52x IDE CD-ROM
Yamaha CRW4416S SCSI CD-RW
Microsoft IntelliMouse Explorer USB
Microsoft SideWinder Force Feedback Pro
US Robotics Sportster Flash v90 External modem
Iiyama Vision Master Pro 17
Adaptec 2940 Ultra Wide SCSI controller
Sound Blaster Live! Value (LiveWare 3)
Windows 2000 Professional (SP1 + all updates)

data/avatar/default/avatar18.webp

989 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-05-12
LO****ingL!
from hardocp.com
"Glide Underground and about 20 other people are all reporting that since 3dfx is "licensing its 4way SLI technology" to Quantum, that they have cancelled the V5-6000. The wording is a little off, but it can also be read that 3dfx licensed the tech to Quantum and QUANTUM'S boards aren't going to be retail...."
 
I knew it ;(

data/avatar/default/avatar12.webp

1915 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-03-30
Well this actually kinda sucked... 3DFX called it quits today for thier video line.musta read this board hehe.. Oh well time to start picking on ATI. And we always have that AMD vs INTEL Holy war

data/avatar/default/avatar25.webp

1297 Posts
Location -
Joined 1999-07-16
Wrong sapiens26 3dfx didn't quits read all thur the Press Releases.http://www.3dfx.com/comp/news/rel-15nov.html

data/avatar/default/avatar12.webp

1915 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-03-30
I meant they wont be manufacturing thier boards....going back to what they used to do ...but i was a bit confused.... other sites have posted that they had quit the video business outright..

data/avatar/default/avatar18.webp

189 Posts
Location -
Joined 1999-12-30
Who cares if they stop manufacturing their boards. You will still be able to buy video cards with 3dfx chips in it. So, ummm, kinda like that company that everyone on this board apparently loves.. NVIDIA! Maybe you will start seeing asus boards with 3dfx chips, or maybe CL....that would be cool. But, anyway, its not that big of a deal. Although, that is very disappointing about the V5 6000. I was looking forward to that card.

data/avatar/default/avatar19.webp

60 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-07-20
Why would anyone be intersted in the v5-6000? The card is a total hack. I usually never particpate in these discussions, but come on. The card is HUGE. It wont fit in some cases due to its size, not to mention th external power it had to draw from. SLI was a cool idea with the Voodoo 2's, I agree. And I think its a pretty cool idea to put 2 on 1 card (ie the v5000), but when you are adding 4 of 1 chip, its just plain unefficent. Ill be intersted to see the rampage, but its gonna get beat by NV20.
 
As far as 3dfx licensing their tech to other companies to fab like Nvidia does, well, 3dfx 2 years ago did the same thing. All the Voodoo 2's were made by 3rd parties. So, they bought STB so they could produce their boards themselves and after a year and a half they decide to give up on production. They killed STB, wasted a lot of money, and put them behind in the video card race. Their only saving grace is the Rampage. But Nvidia is kinda like Microsoft, they are winning each quarter with new products and high performace. 3dfx is loosing money and fan support. Nvidia has more money and momentum in R&D, and 3dfx has further to go to catch up. Rampage better be good if they want their spot on top, its not impossible, but it dosnt look good.
 
Jeff

data/avatar/default/avatar12.webp

1915 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-03-30
I agree but i think 3dfx has put out so many good products and if it werent for them Nvidia wouldnt be here today.. I don't wish them to put out better chips than Nvidia..but at least some competition...I remember that AMD was a joke when comparing it with INTEL chips..but now they are spoken in the same sentence..as equals..I want that of 3dfx .. I think competition is good..good for business and the industry as a whole..we need more innnovators...not monopoloy's..I hope they get their act together and make the best chipsets they can make..they have just lost thier way..Like Intel..doesnt mean they wont come back and take the industry by storm...I hope for the industry they stay in the battle and fight...maybe one day to be on top again..or at least make a contest of it

data/avatar/default/avatar12.webp

1915 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-03-30
you know i just got done making that post..so i turned the tele on and first thing i see is that really Gay P3 commercial...sorry people but that is pretty damn annoying..I was trying to complement INTEL in my twisted way hoping they will step up to the plate and be champions like i know they are...and i see that commercial..well it was funny ...at least to me anyhow

data/avatar/default/avatar31.webp

54 Posts
Location -
Joined 2000-06-03
Reaper_uk"
" just up the res and so FSAA doesn't matter. i think not, even if you put the to 1600X1200 1024X768@4xFSAA, looks a hell of alot better, think i would even prefer 1024x768@2xFSAA. "
 
Funny considering I highly doubt he can run anything well in 1600 x 1200 with a 3dfx chip...
 
------------------
System Specs:
MSI 694D Pro-A Mobo
Dual Gighz pentium III's
320 meg pc 133 sdram
30 Gig Maxtor Ata-100
Geforce 2 GTS
DVD w/ Decoder Card
Sblive etc etc...